Shipping and Returns: How Policy Affects Conversions

Your shipping and returns policies directly impact conversion rates. Customers factor these into their buying decisions—sometimes more than product features or price.

Get these policies right, and you remove major purchase barriers. Get them wrong, and you create anxiety that prevents conversions.

Why Shipping and Returns Matter

The Amazon Effect

Amazon Prime has conditioned customers to expect:

• Free shipping
• Fast delivery (2 days or less)
• Free, easy returns

You may not match Amazon, but you’re competing against these expectations.

Purchase Anxiety

Before clicking “Buy,” customers worry:

• “What’s the total going to be with shipping?”
• “When will it arrive?”
• “What if I don’t like it?”
• “How hard will returns be?”

Your policies either answer these concerns or leave them festering.

The Data

• 56% of cart abandonment cites shipping costs as a factor
• 79% of consumers say free returns are important to their purchase decision
• 68% check return policy before purchasing

Shipping Strategy

Free Shipping

The power of free: “Free shipping” is among the most persuasive offers in e-commerce. Even a small shipping fee creates psychological friction that “free” eliminates.

Options:

• Free shipping on all orders
• Free shipping above threshold ($50+)
• Free shipping for members/subscribers
• Free shipping on certain products

The threshold strategy: “Free shipping on orders over $50” is common because it:

• Increases average order value (customers add items to qualify)
• Reduces margin impact vs. free on everything
• Creates clear value proposition

Finding your threshold:

• Set slightly above current average order value
• Test different thresholds
• Monitor if customers abandon just below threshold

Shipping Speed

What customers want:

• Knowing when it will arrive (certainty)
• Faster is better, but expectations vary by product
• Tracking information

Options to offer:

• Standard (5-7 days)
• Expedited (2-3 days)
• Express/overnight

Show delivery dates, not just speed:

• “Arrives by Friday” is clearer than “3-5 business days”
• Countdown timers: “Order in 2h 15m for Friday delivery”

Shipping Cost Display

Don’t surprise customers: Unexpected shipping costs at checkout are the #1 cause of abandonment.

Best practices:

• Show shipping cost on product pages
• Display threshold for free shipping prominently
• Provide shipping calculator in cart
• No surprises at checkout

Example messaging:

• Header banner: “Free shipping on orders $50+”
• Product page: “Ships free” or “Add $15 more for free shipping”
• Cart: “You’re $12 away from free shipping!”

International Shipping

If you ship internationally:

• Clear list of countries served
• Shipping costs by region
• Delivery timeframe expectations
• Customs/duties information
• Currency clarity

If you don’t ship internationally:

• State clearly to avoid wasted browsing
• Consider expansion—international customers often have fewer local options

Returns Strategy

The Returns Paradox

Intuition: Strict return policies protect profit Reality: Generous return policies often increase profit

Why? Easy returns:

• Reduce purchase anxiety
• Increase conversion rates
• Build trust and loyalty
• Generate positive reviews
• Create confident buyers

The conversion increase typically outweighs return costs.

Key Return Policy Elements

Return window:

• 30 days is standard minimum
• 60-90 days builds more confidence
• “Extended holiday returns” removes seasonal anxiety

Return cost:

• Free returns maximize conversion
• If charging, be clear upfront
• Provide prepaid label option

Condition requirements:

• “Unused with tags” is common
• Some retailers accept used items
• Be specific about what’s acceptable

Refund method:

• Original payment method preferred
• Store credit only may deter purchases
• Timeline for refund processing

Communicating Returns

Where to display:

• Footer link (expected location)
• Product pages (near buy button)
• Cart and checkout pages
• Confirmation emails

How to communicate:

• Plain language, not legalese
• Key points in bullets
• Full policy available but summary prominent

Example summary: “Free 30-day returns. No questions asked. Free prepaid shipping label included with order.”

Returns and Trust

Returns policy signals your confidence in the product:

• Generous returns = “We stand behind our quality”
• Strict returns = “We’re worried you won’t like it”

This perception matters even to customers who never return items.

Messaging That Converts

Shipping Messages

Homepage/header:

• “Free shipping on all orders”
• “Free 2-day shipping on orders $50+”
• “Fast, free delivery”

Product page:

• “Free shipping” (if applicable)
• “Get it by [date]” with dynamic calculation
• “In stock — ships today”

Cart:

• “Free shipping!” (if qualified)
• “Add $X for free shipping” (if not)
• Delivery date estimate

Returns Messages

Homepage/header:

• “Free returns”
• “30-day money-back guarantee”
• “Easy returns”

Product page:

• “Free 30-day returns”
• “Don’t love it? Send it back free”
• Link to full policy

Checkout:

• “Remember: free returns if you change your mind”
• Reduces checkout anxiety

Trust Badge Placement

Place shipping/returns trust badges:

• Near add-to-cart button
• In cart summary
• Near payment form in checkout
• Footer (always visible)

Operational Considerations

Can You Afford Free Shipping?

Calculate true cost:

• Average shipping cost per order
• Current conversion rate
• Average order value
• Expected conversion lift from free shipping

Example:

• Average shipping cost: $6
• Current conversion rate: 2.5%
• Expected lift from free shipping: +20%
• New conversion rate: 3.0%

If the additional 0.5% conversions cover the $6 cost (they usually do), free shipping is profitable.

Can You Afford Free Returns?

Calculate true cost:

• Return rate (typically 5-30% depending on category)
• Shipping cost per return
• Restocking/processing cost
• Percentage returned items resellable

Most categories find:

• Return rate increase from generous policy is modest
• Conversion increase outweighs return cost
• Returned items often resellable

Reducing Return Rates

If returns are problematic, address root causes:

• Better product photos (accurate expectations)
• Detailed size guides (reduces apparel returns)
• Accurate descriptions (reduces “not as expected”)
• Quality control (reduces defectives)
• Better packaging (reduces shipping damage)

Policy Design Best Practices

Be Generous

Within reason, more generous policies convert better:

• Longer return windows
• Free return shipping
• No-questions-asked attitude
• Prepaid labels included

Be Clear

Ambiguity creates anxiety:

• Plain language
• Specific timeframes
• Clear process steps
• FAQ for edge cases

Be Consistent

Policy should match execution:

• Don’t make generous promises you won’t keep
• Train customer service on policy
• Honor stated terms without friction

Be Competitive

Know what competitors offer:

• Match or beat industry standard
• If you can’t match, differentiate elsewhere
• Highlight where you exceed competitors

Testing Policy Changes

What to Test

• Free shipping threshold levels
• Return window length
• Impact of “free returns” messaging
• Placement of policy information
• Messaging variations

How to Measure

Primary metrics:

• Conversion rate
• Average order value
• Revenue per visitor

Secondary metrics:

• Return rate
• Shipping cost per order
• Customer satisfaction scores
• Repeat purchase rate

Be Patient

Policy changes may take time to impact behavior:

• Customers need to discover new policy
• Word-of-mouth and reviews take time
• Measure over meaningful time period (4-8 weeks minimum)

Shipping and Returns Checklist

Shipping

• Free shipping offered (or path to it)
• Shipping cost visible before checkout
• Delivery dates clearly communicated
• Multiple speed options available
• Threshold for free shipping strategic and clear

Returns

• Return window is competitive (30+ days)
• Return process is clearly explained
• Free returns offered (or clearly priced)
• Prepaid label available
• Refund timeline stated

Communication

• Key policies in header/banner
• Policy info on product pages
• Trust badges near CTAs
• Clear policy page linked from footer
• Policy included in confirmation emails

Ready to Improve Your Conversions?

Get a comprehensive CRO audit with actionable insights you can implement right away.

Request Your Audit — $2,500