Upselling and Cross-Selling: Boost Average Order Value

Acquiring a customer is expensive. Once they’re ready to buy, increasing their order value is one of the most efficient ways to grow revenue.

Upselling and cross-selling, done right, serve customers by helping them find better solutions. Done wrong, they feel pushy and damage trust.

This guide covers strategies that increase average order value while keeping customers happy.

Definitions

Upselling

Encouraging customers to buy a more expensive version of the product they’re considering.

Examples:

• “Upgrade to the Pro plan for just $10/month more”
• “The 256GB model is only $100 more”
• “Consider our premium leather version”

Cross-Selling

Encouraging customers to buy complementary products alongside their main purchase.

Examples:

• “Add a case for your new phone”
• “Customers also bought these accessories”
• “Complete your outfit with matching items”

Bundling

Combining multiple products at a discounted total price.

Examples:

• “Buy the camera + lens + bag and save 15%”
• “Starter kit includes everything you need”
• “The complete set at 20% off”

Why These Strategies Work

Customer Value

Done right, these aren’t tricks—they’re helpful:

• Customers genuinely might want accessories
• Upgrades often provide real additional value
• Bundles simplify decision-making
• Customers appreciate relevant suggestions

Business Impact

Example math:

• Monthly orders: 5,000
• Current AOV: $60
• Monthly revenue: $300,000

With 15% AOV increase:

• New AOV: $69
• New monthly revenue: $345,000
• Additional monthly revenue: $45,000

Small AOV increases compound significantly.

Upselling Strategies

Product Page Upsells

Show upgrade options clearly:

• Compare tiers/versions on product page
• Highlight what users get with upgrade
• Make price difference feel small (“just $20 more”)
• Emphasize value gained vs. price increase

Example: “Upgrade to 256GB for just $100 more and never worry about storage again”

Cart Upsells

Before checkout:

• “Upgrade your selection” option in cart
• Show comparison of what they chose vs. next tier
• One-click upgrade button

Checkout Upsells

During checkout (carefully):

• Simple, single upgrade option
• Don’t complicate the checkout flow
• Make it dismissible without friction

Post-Purchase Upsells

After order confirmation:

• “Add this to your order” (if fulfillment allows)
• Discount on upgrade for next purchase
• Email follow-up with upgrade offer

Effective Upsell Copy

Focus on value, not features:

• ❌ “The Pro has 2TB storage”
• ✅ “Never delete a photo again with Pro’s 2TB storage”

Make the price difference feel small:

• ❌ “Upgrade for $120”
• ✅ “Just $10/month more” or “Only $0.33/day”

Create contrast:

• Show what they’re missing without upgrade
• Quantify the difference in value vs. price

Cross-Selling Strategies

”Frequently Bought Together”

On product pages: Show 2-3 items commonly purchased with this product:

• Include images
• Show total price with “Add all to cart”
• Offer small discount for buying together

Data-driven recommendations:

• Use actual purchase data
• Products that genuinely complement each other
• Not random suggestions

”Complete the Look” / “Complete the Set”

For visual/lifestyle products:

• Fashion: Show outfit combinations
• Home: Show styled room groupings
• Electronics: Show full setup

Accessory Suggestions

Required accessories:

• Batteries not included? Suggest them
• Cable needed? Add to suggestions
• Protective case? Offer it

Enhancement accessories:

• Extended warranty
• Premium add-ons
• Carrying cases or storage

Cart Cross-Sells

In the cart:

• “Don’t forget” section
• Low-commitment add-ons
• Items that complement cart contents

Keep it limited:

• 3-4 suggestions maximum
• Don’t overwhelm or distract from checkout

Post-Purchase Cross-Sells

Confirmation page:

• “Add to your order” (time-limited)
• Relevant accessories for what they bought

Follow-up emails:

• “How to get the most from your [product]”
• Accessory suggestions based on purchase

Bundling Strategies

Product Bundles

Create logical combinations:

• Starter kits for beginners
• Complete solutions for a use case
• Best-seller bundles

Price attractively:

• Show original total vs. bundle price
• Make savings clear and significant (15%+ off)
• Don’t discount so heavily that margin disappears

Tiered Bundles

Good-Better-Best:

• Basic: Core product only
• Standard: Product + essential accessories
• Premium: Product + accessories + extended warranty

Build-Your-Own Bundles

Let customers create their own:

• “Buy any 3, get 20% off”
• Mix-and-match with volume discount
• Increases AOV while giving control

Placement and Timing

Where to Show Upsells/Cross-Sells

Location	Best For	Caution
Product page	Cross-sells, upgrades	Don’t distract from main product
Cart	Quick add-ons	Keep checkout path clear
Checkout	Simple additions	Minimal friction—one option max
Confirmation	Add-ons to order	Time-sensitive, low pressure
Email	Follow-up suggestions	Don’t be annoying

Timing Principles

Early in journey: Discovery-oriented suggestions At decision point: Upgrade options In cart: Complementary items At checkout: Minimal, high-relevance only Post-purchase: Next-purchase incentives

Making Recommendations Relevant

Use Data

Collaborative filtering: “Customers who bought X also bought Y”

Product relationships: Define complementary items in your catalog

Purchase history: For returning customers, use past purchases to inform suggestions

Context Matters

What’s in their cart: Suggest items that complement, not compete with, their selection

What they’ve viewed: Session behavior indicates interests

What they’ve bought before: Don’t suggest what they already own (unless consumable)

Relevance Beats Volume

3 relevant suggestions outperform 12 random ones. Quality over quantity.

Avoiding Pushiness

Respect the Primary Goal

The customer came to buy something specific. Don’t distract or confuse with aggressive suggestions.

Easy Dismissal

• Clear “No thanks” option
• Suggestions shouldn’t block checkout progress
• Don’t ask repeatedly after dismissal

Honest Value

• Only suggest items that genuinely complement
• Don’t oversell features
• Be transparent about what’s included

Appropriate Frequency

• One upsell attempt per session is usually enough
• Don’t repeat rejected offers
• Vary suggestions, don’t spam the same items

Measuring Success

Key Metrics

Average Order Value (AOV): Total revenue ÷ Number of orders

Upsell/Cross-sell Conversion Rate: Offers accepted ÷ Offers shown

Revenue Per Visitor: Total revenue ÷ Total visitors

Attach Rate: Orders with add-ons ÷ Total orders

Attribution

Track which suggestions drive additional revenue:

• Which product combinations perform best?
• Which placement converts highest?
• What’s the lift vs. control (no suggestions)?

Watch for Negatives

Monitor for unintended consequences:

• Does aggressive upselling increase cart abandonment?
• Do returns increase with bundled items?
• Are customers satisfied with their purchases?

A/B Testing Upsells

What to Test

• Suggestion placement (product page vs. cart)
• Number of suggestions (2 vs. 4)
• Discount levels on bundles
• Copy variations
• Visual presentation

Test Carefully

Upselling directly affects revenue. Test with statistical rigor:

• Adequate sample sizes
• Track both conversion rate AND AOV
• Watch for segment differences
• Monitor cart abandonment rate

Quick Implementation Ideas

Easy Wins

1. Add “Frequently bought together” to product pages

   • Start with manual curation
   • 3 complementary items with “Add all” button

2. Create 3 starter bundles

   • Bundle top-seller with accessories
   • 15-20% discount vs. separate purchase

3. Cart add-on section

   • Show 2-3 low-cost complementary items
   • Quick “Add” button

4. Post-purchase email

   • “Complete your setup” with accessory suggestions
   • Sent 2-3 days after delivery

More Advanced

• Personalized recommendations based on browsing
• Dynamic bundles based on cart contents
• Loyalty-program exclusive bundles
• AI-powered recommendation engine

Upselling Checklist

• Product pages show upgrade options where relevant
• “Frequently bought together” implemented
• Cart shows complementary item suggestions
• Bundles created for top products
• Post-purchase email includes relevant cross-sells
• Suggestions are data-driven and relevant
• Dismissal is easy and respected
• AOV and attach rate are being tracked
• A/B testing methodology in place

Ready to Improve Your Conversions?

Get a comprehensive CRO audit with actionable insights you can implement right away.

Request Your Audit — $2,500